Watch Condition Ranks Explained: MINT, Near MINT and Excellent +5

Every watch on this site carries a condition rank. If you have not bought a pre-owned watch from Japan before, those ranks are the single most useful thing on the page — they tell you, in one line, what forty years of someone else's daily wear actually did to the watch you are looking at.

This guide explains what each rank means, why we grade the case and the bracelet separately, and what the condition notes underneath are actually describing.

The seven ranks

We grade every watch by hand in our Tokyo workshop, using the same scale for all of them:

Rank What it means
MINT (Vintage MINT) Almost unused. Excellent condition throughout.
NEAR MINT Very light wear. Great overall condition.
EXCELLENT +5 Light wear. Well kept and functional.
EXCELLENT +4 Moderate wear, consistent with age.
EXCELLENT +3 Noticeable wear. Functional.
GOOD Heavy wear with visible marks.
AS-IS / PARTS For parts or repair. Not fully tested.

A few things worth knowing about how we apply this scale.

MINT does not mean new. On a watch from 1972, MINT means the piece survived fifty years without being worn hard — not that it left the factory yesterday. We use it sparingly.

The jump from NEAR MINT to EXCELLENT +5 is smaller than it looks. Both describe a watch that has clearly been looked after. The difference is usually how the case edges and the bracelet links have held up.

GOOD is honest, not a warning. A GOOD vintage Seiko with a crisp dial can be a better buy than a NEAR MINT quartz piece nobody wants. The rank describes cosmetics, not desirability.

Why there are two ranks

Look at the Condition Rank section of any listing and you will see two lines:

  • Body Rank — the case, bezel, case back, crystal, dial and hands
  • Belt / Bracelet Rank — the strap or bracelet and the buckle

We separate them because they almost never wear at the same rate. A bracelet takes the brunt of daily use while the case sits protected on top of the wrist, so it is common to see a NEAR MINT body on an EXCELLENT +5 bracelet. It is also the part you can most easily change: a tired bracelet on an otherwise excellent watch is a much smaller problem than a scratched dial.

If a strap is not the one the watch left the factory with, we say so in the condition notes.

Reading the condition notes

Above the ranks, each listing has a Condition Details section that goes part by part. The notes are deliberately plain:

・Case: Many scratch (The entire)
・Crystal: No damage
・Dial: No damage
・Buckle: Many scratch, deep scratch (The entire, In some places)

Read this together with the photos rather than instead of them. We photograph every watch ourselves, under the same lighting, and the marks described in the notes are visible in the images. If a listing says the case has scratches across the whole surface, you should be able to find them in the photos — and if you cannot, ask us.

What the operation note covers

Every listing includes a line about whether the watch is running:

The watch has been checked and is running properly at the time of listing. As this is a pre-owned watch, accuracy and long-term performance cannot be guaranteed.

This is the honest position on a mechanical object that is often older than the person buying it. We check that it runs, and on many vintage pieces we note the daily rate we measured. What we cannot do is promise how a fifty-year-old movement will behave in a year.

Two practical points:

Quartz watches and batteries. A quartz watch that runs on our bench can stop in transit — the battery may simply be near the end of its life. Replacing it is inexpensive and normal. If a watch arrives stopped and a fresh battery does not fix it, that is a fault and our return policy covers it.

Water resistance. Any water resistance figure in the specifications is the original factory rating. On a vintage watch with decades-old gaskets, treat it as history rather than a promise, and have the watch pressure-tested before it gets near water.

Where the ranks come from

Nothing here is automated. The same people who photograph the watches write the condition notes, and the ranks reflect what they see on the bench. We say so in every listing: the assessment is our own opinion.

That cuts both ways. It means the grading is consistent across our whole catalogue, because it is the same eyes and the same scale every time. It also means it is a judgement, not a measurement — so the photos and the part-by-part notes matter more than the single-word rank.

If you are weighing up two watches and the ranks are not telling you enough, email us at info@froevo.com and ask. We have the watch in hand.

Start browsing

ブログに戻る